On Friday, yet another
school official managed to attempt to openly ban a book. Cory
Doctorow's book Little Brother
was removed
from a summer reading program
because of its “positive view of questioning authority, lauding
'hacker culture', and sex and sexuality in passing.” This was the
act of the principal of the Booker T. Washington High School in
Pensacola, FL. In the end, the entire summer reading program was
ended. The book is on the optional list for students in 11th
grade now but it's sad that one man could nix a reading program that
might have proved to be educational for students.
Cory
Doctorow and his publisher Tor are sending 200 copies of the book to
the school for free. He has a great response here.
I think it's brilliant. I also think the principal was an idiot for
stopping the summer program.
I
will admit I haven't read the book, but what I've read about it I
can't see anything wrong with it. I'm not a school administrator, but
from what I understand the book was already approved before the
principal decided to yank it.
I
have a problem with schools trying to stop students from reading what
they think might be controversial books. In Idaho, a book that
parents and administrators felt was too much for the teenagers, The
True Diary of a Part-Time Indian,
was
banned
because of some parts the adults didn't think the children should
read – including discussions of profanity and masturbation. 10Th
graders already know about that for the most part. I don't see any
reason why they shouldn't be allowed to read it. A student got some
free copies and was passing them out in a park to kids who wanted to
read them. Parents
called the police on her
because they didn't approve of it.
I
know I posted
about the thought of trigger warnings on books.
I could see both sides of the argument. I rescind my view in that
post. Trigger warnings should not be put on books. Banning books
because of content should not be allowed. People should read books
that challenge their views on the world, that are disturbing to them,
to get them to think.
I bet if she was handing out copies of the Bible no one would have called the police on her. Despite, you know, all the violent stories (I think there's one that involves masturbation, too).
ReplyDeleteIt's been so long since I read the Bible I couldn't tell you what's in it anymore. But yeah, if she'd been handing out Bibles - or around here Book of Mormons - she'd have been left alone.
Delete